2024
Grace Adkins
Ashlynn Deans

2023
Kaitlyn Evans
Nellie Gownley
Lyndsey Miller
Savanna Reitz
Julia Sokolowski

2022
Autumn Foster-Fields
Madison Hobbs
Savanna Reitz
Madison Shaner
Elsa Skinner

2021 - No Season (COVID)
2020 - No Season (COVID)

2019
Lacey Hinkle
Jordan Snyder
Natalie Sonntag
Bridgette Tayman

2018
Alyssa Baronella O' Toole
Sofia Michael
Madeline Szanyi

2017
Sofia Michael
Emily Rowe
Alyssa Yates

2016
Elaine Draper
Emily Rowe
Renee Ruppert

2014
Kathleen Gehrdes

2013
Brittani Biddinger
Meghenn Jackson
Shannon O'Neal

2012
Sam Adams
Meghenn Jackson
Mary Milligan
Karlee Zywusko

2011
Cloey Henchcliffe
Erica McMahon
Mary Milligan

2010
Jenny Miller
Megan Schrum

2009
Kellie Kroneberger
Andrea Zoolakis

2008
Brittany Griffin
Bryanna Vohs

2007
Ashleigh Gender
Springanne Hatfield
Courtney Highsmith (National Offensive Player of the Year)
Sarah Maggio
Kristine Schafer

2006
Jenn Bohannan
Courtney Highsmith
Ali Napolitano
Kristine Schafer 

2005
Jenny Deans
Jenn Gappert
Kristen Kibler
Jen Marshall

2004
Jenny Deans
Kim Evans
Jenn Gappert